☆ 23 Oct 2021 · SCO · Scottish Cup St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers 1–3 Gala Fairydean Rovers
☆ 18 Sep 2021 · SCO · Scottish Cup Wigtown & Bladnoch WB Wigtown & Bladnoch 0–8 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers
☆ 16 Aug 2014 · SCO · Scottish Cup Auchinleck Talbot 5–1 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers
☆ 05 Oct 2013 · SCO · Scottish Cup Auchinleck Talbot 4–0 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers
☆ 14 Sep 2013 · SCO · Scottish Cup Hawick Royal Albert HR Hawick Royal Albert 0–1 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers
☆ 25 Aug 2012 · SCO · Scottish Cup Edinburgh University 1–2 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers
☆ 26 Sep 2009 · SCO · Scottish Cup Inverurie Loco Works 5–0 St Cuthbert Wanderers SC St Cuthbert Wanderers