Head-to-head
Aggregate
Played9
Draws333.3%
Goals St James's Gate14
Goals Shelbourne15
St James's Gate winsdrawsShelbourne wins
All meetings
| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Feb 1944 | St James's Gate | 1–3 |
|
A | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 14 Feb 1940 |
Shelbourne
|
3–4 | St James's Gate | A | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 03 Feb 1940 | St James's Gate | 1–1 |
|
D | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 11 Feb 1939 |
Shelbourne
|
2–0 | St James's Gate | H | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 13 Jan 1937 | St James's Gate | 4–2 |
|
H | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 09 Jan 1937 |
Shelbourne
|
1–1 | St James's Gate | D | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 20 Jan 1923 | St James's Gate | 1–2 |
|
A | IRL · FAI Cup |
| 04 Mar 1922 | St James's Gate | 2–1 |
|
H | IRL · FAI Cup Semi-final |
| 18 Feb 1922 | St James's Gate | 0–0 |
|
D | IRL · FAI Cup Semi-final |