Head-to-head
Aggregate
All meetings
| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Jun 2015 | Paraguay | 1–0 | Jamaica | H | ITL · Copa América |
| 09 Jul 2003 | Jamaica | 2–0 | Paraguay | H | ITL · Friendly |
| 31 Mar 1999 | Jamaica | 3–0 | Paraguay | H | ITL · Friendly |
| 05 Mar 1999 | Jamaica | 1–3 | Paraguay | A | ITL · Friendly |
| 12 Mar 1989 | Jamaica | 0–3 | Paraguay | A | ITL · Friendly |
| 05 Feb 1986 | Jamaica | 1–4 | Paraguay | A | ITL · Miami Cup |