| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Apr 2017 |
Solihull Moors
|
1–2 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 08 Apr 2017 |
Chester
|
0–2 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 04 Apr 2017 |
York City
|
0–2 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 01 Apr 2017 |
York City
|
3–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 28 Mar 2017 |
Macclesfield Town
|
1–3 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 25 Mar 2017 |
Dagenham & Redbridge
|
1–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 21 Mar 2017 |
York City
|
5–3 | Southport | H | ENG · National League |
| 11 Mar 2017 |
Sutton United
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 04 Mar 2017 |
York City
|
3–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 28 Feb 2017 |
Lincoln City
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 21 Feb 2017 |
York City
|
1–3 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 18 Feb 2017 |
Boreham Wood
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 11 Feb 2017 |
York City
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 28 Jan 2017 |
Aldershot Town
|
0–0 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 21 Jan 2017 |
York City
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 07 Jan 2017 |
Dover Athletic
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 01 Jan 2017 |
York City
|
0–1 | North Ferriby United | A | ENG · National League |
| 26 Dec 2016 | North Ferriby United | 0–1 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 17 Dec 2016 |
York City
|
0–0 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 03 Dec 2016 |
Tranmere Rovers
|
1–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 29 Nov 2016 |
York City
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 26 Nov 2016 |
Bromley
|
3–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 22 Nov 2016 |
York City
|
1–4 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 19 Nov 2016 |
York City
|
0–2 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 12 Nov 2016 |
Eastleigh
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 29 Oct 2016 |
York City
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 25 Oct 2016 | Southport | 2–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 22 Oct 2016 |
York City
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 08 Oct 2016 |
Braintree Town
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 04 Oct 2016 |
Guiseley
|
6–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 01 Oct 2016 |
York City
|
0–1 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 24 Sep 2016 |
Barrow
|
2–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 17 Sep 2016 |
York City
|
0–1 |
|
A | ENG · National League |
| 13 Sep 2016 |
York City
|
0–0 |
|
D | ENG · National League |
| 10 Sep 2016 |
Torquay United
|
2–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 03 Sep 2016 |
York City
|
4–0 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 29 Aug 2016 |
Wrexham
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 27 Aug 2016 |
York City
|
4–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 20 Aug 2016 |
Forest Green Rovers
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |
| 16 Aug 2016 |
Gateshead
|
6–1 |
|
H | ENG · National League |