| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Mar 1901 |
Wolverhampton Wanderers
|
0–4 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 3 |
| 23 Feb 1901 |
Sheffield United
|
2–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 09 Feb 1901 |
Sunderland
|
1–2 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 01 Mar 1900 |
Bury
|
2–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 3 |
| 24 Feb 1900 |
Sheffield United
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 3 |
| 19 Feb 1900 |
Sheffield Wednesday
|
0–2 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 17 Feb 1900 |
Sheffield United
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 27 Jan 1900 |
Sheffield United
|
1–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 15 Apr 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
4–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Final |
| 30 Mar 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
1–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Semi-final |
| 23 Mar 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
4–4 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Semi-final |
| 18 Mar 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Semi-final |
| 25 Feb 1899 |
Nottingham Forest
|
0–1 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 3 |
| 16 Feb 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 11 Feb 1899 |
Preston North End
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 02 Feb 1899 |
Sheffield United
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 28 Jan 1899 |
Burnley
|
2–2 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 02 Feb 1898 |
Port Vale
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 29 Jan 1898 |
Sheffield United
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 30 Jan 1897 |
Blackburn Rovers
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 15 Feb 1896 |
Everton
|
3–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 06 Feb 1896 |
Sheffield United
|
1–0 | Burton Wanderers | H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 01 Feb 1896 | Burton Wanderers | 1–1 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 20 Feb 1895 |
West Bromwich Albion
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 16 Feb 1895 |
Sheffield United
|
1–1 |
|
D | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 02 Feb 1895 |
Sheffield United
|
3–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 27 Jan 1894 |
Newcastle United
|
2–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 04 Feb 1893 |
Sheffield United
|
1–3 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 21 Jan 1893 |
Blackpool
|
1–3 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 30 Jan 1892 |
Wolverhampton Wanderers
|
3–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 16 Jan 1892 |
Blackpool
|
0–3 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 17 Jan 1891 |
Sheffield United
|
1–9 |
|
A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 01 Feb 1890 |
Bolton Wanderers
|
13–0 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 18 Jan 1890 |
Sheffield United
|
2–1 |
|
H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |