| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Apr 1959 | Guernsey | 2–3 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 01 May 1958 | Jersey | 2–1 | Guernsey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 27 Mar 1958 | Guernsey | 8–2 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 02 May 1957 | Guernsey | 6–4 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 03 May 1956 | Jersey | 2–1 | Guernsey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 22 Mar 1956 | Guernsey | 4–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 30 May 1955 | Jersey | 1–0 | Guernsey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 05 May 1955 | Guernsey | 0–0 | Jersey | D | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 06 May 1954 | Jersey | 3–5 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 01 Apr 1954 | Guernsey | 2–1 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 30 Apr 1953 | Guernsey | 0–2 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 01 May 1952 | Jersey | 1–3 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 03 Apr 1952 | Guernsey | 7–2 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 03 May 1951 | Guernsey | 3–1 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 04 May 1950 | Jersey | 0–2 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 30 Mar 1950 | Guernsey | 3–1 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 05 May 1949 | Guernsey | 1–2 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 06 May 1948 | Jersey | 6–3 | Guernsey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 15 Apr 1948 | Guernsey | 3–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 01 May 1947 | Guernsey | 1–3 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 02 May 1946 | Guernsey | 0–4 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 11 Apr 1946 | Jersey | 7–0 | Guernsey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 04 May 1939 | Guernsey | 0–1 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 05 May 1938 | Guernsey | 3–1 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 28 Apr 1938 | Guernsey | 4–3 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 17 May 1937 | Guernsey | 3–3 | Jersey | D | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 29 Apr 1937 | Jersey | 2–2 | Guernsey | D | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 15 Apr 1937 | Guernsey | 4–1 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 07 May 1936 | Guernsey | 2–1 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 09 May 1935 | Guernsey | 5–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 11 Apr 1935 | Jersey | 0–1 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 26 Apr 1934 | Jersey | 0–1 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 12 Apr 1934 | Guernsey | 3–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 04 May 1933 | Guernsey | 4–1 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 28 Apr 1932 | Guernsey | 4–2 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 14 Apr 1932 | Guernsey | 2–0 | Jersey | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 30 Apr 1931 | Guernsey | 2–4 | Jersey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 16 Apr 1931 | Guernsey | 1–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 01 May 1930 | Jersey | 2–3 | Guernsey | A | ITL · Muratti Vase |
| 02 May 1929 | Guernsey | 5–0 | Alderney | H | ITL · Muratti Vase |