| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Oct 1887 | Crusaders | 3–2 | Old Wykehamists | H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 15 Oct 1887 | Crusaders | 9–0 | Lyndhurst | H | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |
| 13 Nov 1886 | Old Carthusians | 4–2 | Crusaders | H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 23 Oct 1886 | Clapton | 0–5 | Crusaders | A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |