| Date | Home | Score | Away | R | Tournament |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Nov 1873 | Clapham Rovers | 1–1 | Cambridge University | D | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 23 Nov 1872 | Clapham Rovers | 0–3 | Oxford University | A | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 16 Dec 1871 | Wanderers | 3–1 | Clapham Rovers | H | ENG · FA Cup Round 2 |
| 11 Nov 1871 | Upton Park | 0–3 | Clapham Rovers | A | ENG · FA Cup Round 1 |